Posted by jonathan at 1:02pm EST on 10/22/2007
So there have still been some things on my mind about paid links and that whole situation. I thought, “what better way to get some answers then to e-mail Matt directly for some feedback.” I was completely mistaken when I thought, for even a second, that I would get a real response.
I just received this e-mail, here is what it says…
This is the Webmaster Central team respectfully sending you an automated
reply… so that:
– Matt can unbury himself from gazillions of e-mails and better achieve a
healthy work/life balance
– You can get the help and information you need more efficiently by
leveraging the vast Webmaster Central resources available.
A real (non-Matt) human will very likely read your note, but likely won’t
have a chance to respond.
* * *
Here are some resources we encourage you to check out:
* Webmaster-related concerns, questions, bug reports
Check out our new and improved Webmaster Central at
You’ll find hundreds of detailed help documents, many powerful tools, and
a friendly discussion forum. We especially welcome you to post questions
and suggestions in this discussion group, which is frequented by a
substantial number of helpful Googlers and non-Googlers alike.
* Webspam / quality concerns
We now have two ways that you can alert us to spam in our search results.
Better: https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/spamreport (requires you
to have a free Webmaster Tools account)
* Web page removal requests
You’ll find full info here:
* Reconsideration request
If your site’s presence in Google has been suddenly and negatively
affected, it may have violated our Webmaster Guidelines
If you suspect that this is the case, please fully address the situation
and then file a reconsideration request
(https://www.google.com/webmasters/tools/reconsideration). Note that
you’ll need to have signed up for our free Webmaster Tools service in
order to file this request. If you haven’t already done so, you can sign
up and verify your site in minutes.
* Interview or speaker requests
If you’d like Matt or another Googler to speak at your event, please fill
out the form at https://services.google.com/inquiry/speaker_request. If
you’re interested in interviewing Matt or one of his trusty colleagues,
please drop a note to firstname.lastname@example.org.
* Questions or comments on various Google products and services such as
AdSense, Calendar, Gmail…
Visit http://www.google.com/support/ for a directory with resources that
will address your questions, enable you to submit feedback, and often
highlight a user-to-user discussion group about that product.
* Have a concern that’s not covered above?
You can visit http://www.google.com/contact/ for other resources. Please
note, however, that we do not offer technical support by phone or e-mail
for webmaster- or search-related issues.
* * *
Thanks for your understanding with this, and take care…
The Webmaster Central team
What did I write to Matt? Here is the e-mail that I wrote to him…
From: Jonathan Dingman
Subject: Paid Links
Date: Fri, 19 Oct 2007 14:24:42 -0400
It’s been a pleasure to meet up you with the few times, but I have a
question for you.
There are thousands upon thousands of sponsored links out there. Why is
Google trying to fight the battle that is useless?
Let’s take a look at this example:
Those are essentially “paid” links, but Google isn’t doc’ing them for
the paid links. What makes them “better” to avoid being banned or
penalized for “paid” links?
I’m eager to hear your thoughts Matt.
So what am I to conclude of this? Matt doesn’t care about responding to e-mails, even if he has a “gazillion” e-mails. I’ve sent countless e-mails to Adam Lasnik and other Google employees and they have been more than happy to respond to them, but not Matt, no, definitely not.
When I met up with Matt at SES San Jose, he seemed like a cool guy, but I guess this proves my positive-assumptions wrong.
Update: Matt did respond so I know he’s not a robot. A fair enough comment as well. See below for his comment.